Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion GroupsGeneralRural LivingHome AutomationSecurity AlarmsConstructionRepairPlumbingCleaningPest ControlLawn and Garden

Homeowner Forum / Repair / February 2004



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Remote Control Switch

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Rob Gray - 29 Feb 2004 06:48 GMT
I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.

I have lights mounted on the outside of my house just below the roofline
(2 story house with attic). I guess these would be called flood lights
since they light up the yard from their mount on the house. There is one
wall switch inside the house that turns on these lights. The thing is
that often the time you need these lights the most is when you drive up
to the house at night (house is in the country, so unless there is a
bright moon, there is no other light source except these lights).

What I am looking for is a wireless remote control wall light switch. In
the past when I asked this question, some people have noted that they
thought that a garage door remote could be modified for this use (since
garage door remotes often can turn on the door opener and/or a garage
light switch). I pursued this angle at a few garage door dealers, but
they said that this use was not a feasible use of their equipment. A
motion detector light is not feasible either since these lights are all
on one circuit and there are about 10 lights around the house.

Does anyone know of a company that sells a wireless remote control wall
light switch? Such a solution would work great since the remote control
unit could be kept in the car and the lights could be switched on when
needed and then simply turned off using he wall switch when the house
has been entered.

Thank in advance for any advice.

Rob
volts500 - 29 Feb 2004 07:19 GMT
> I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
> luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.
[quoted text clipped - 25 lines]
>
> Rob

www.x10.com
Rob Gray - 29 Feb 2004 10:55 GMT
>>I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
>>luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.
[quoted text clipped - 27 lines]
>
> www.x10.com

Thanks for the response. I've been there before and they have things
that are sorta/kinda what I want, but not anything that does what I want
specifically....  Thanks for the idea though....
volts500 - 29 Feb 2004 15:55 GMT
There are _several_ ways to use X-10 to do _exactly_ what you want.  One
way, if your total watts is 500 or less is to replace your existing switch
with the Wall Switch Module (WS467-HA), then plug in a Wireless Transceiver
Module to any receptacle outlet in any inside room close to the driveway and
then set the house codes of the transceiver to control the Wall Switch
Module.  Then use the wireless keychain remote from your car to control the
transceiver.  It's best to try to purchase those three items in a "kit",
you'll get more stuff plus it will probably be cheaper.  If your existing
lights are over 500 watts try installing lower watt light bulbs.   Like I
said, that's just one of several ways to do what you want.

> >>I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
> >>luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.
[quoted text clipped - 31 lines]
> that are sorta/kinda what I want, but not anything that does what I want
> specifically....  Thanks for the idea though....
Rob Gray - 29 Feb 2004 17:10 GMT
> There are _several_ ways to use X-10 to do _exactly_ what you want.  One
> way, if your total watts is 500 or less is to replace your existing switch
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> lights are over 500 watts try installing lower watt light bulbs.   Like I
> said, that's just one of several ways to do what you want.

Cool, thanks for the info. The stupid thing is that I'm not sure if the
current load is over 500 watts. I'll take a look at the total number of
bulbs and figure that out.....
lowspauld - 29 Feb 2004 07:19 GMT
> I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
> luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.
[quoted text clipped - 25 lines]
>
> Rob

Just saw that thing at home depot.  Remote works up to 50' away I believe.
It was in the outdoor lighting section, with the motion detectors.
Rob Gray - 29 Feb 2004 10:54 GMT
>>I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
>>luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.
[quoted text clipped - 28 lines]
> Just saw that thing at home depot.  Remote works up to 50' away I believe.
> It was in the outdoor lighting section, with the motion detectors.

Thanks for the respnse, but as noted in my post I am not looking for a
system using a motion detector. I want one that uses a remote to turn on
the lights...... If a motion detector could be set up somewhat easily to
work on an existing circuit with many lights already installed, then I
might go that route, but the motion detector units I've seen work on a
single light system....
Klm - 29 Feb 2004 07:46 GMT
>I pursued this angle at a few garage door dealers, but
>they said that this use was not a feasible use of their equipment.

In industrial controls there are limit switches.

See  Eaton Electrical Limit Switches at  
http://www.eatonelectrical.com/NASApp/cs/ContentServer?pagename=C-H/Common/Asset
TemplateLink&c=Apubarticles&cid=986495728774&Sec=products

to get an idea what they look like.

The switch lever with the roller can be installed at and activated at
any position by the garage door.
Rob Gray - 29 Feb 2004 11:00 GMT
>>I pursued this angle at a few garage door dealers, but
>>they said that this use was not a feasible use of their equipment.
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
> The switch lever with the roller can be installed at and activated at
> any position by the garage door.

Cool site, thanks... I'll have to dig into the specs at their site more
to confirm that these switches are wireless and remote though. To me it
was not clear from the specific page whether or not they are, but it is
a good start. I don't want a switch that is mounted outside though, I'm
looking for a wireless remote speciically. From a quick glance, their
product looks like a switch that is wired and mounted outdoors.... ...
Thanks again!
Klm - 29 Feb 2004 16:51 GMT
>> In industrial controls there are limit switches.
>>
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>was not clear from the specific page whether or not they are, but it is
>a good start.

There is  no remote control. You turn the lights on (or off) with the
garage door movement at a preset (limit) position.

The switch actuator is entirely mechanical.  Mount the switch on (or
next to) the garage door track so that the edge of the door, or a
raised bump somewhere on the door will depress the lever.  The roller
on the lever is to prevent snagging.  There are also versions with a
plain lever and no  roller.

>I don't want a switch that is mounted outside though, I'm
>looking for a wireless remote speciically. From a quick glance, their
>product looks like a switch that is wired and mounted outdoors.... ...

The switch is weatherproof and I believe proof against sparking
combustible gasses.  It can be mounted anywhere.
Klm - 29 Feb 2004 17:04 GMT
>There is  no remote control. You turn the lights on (or off) with the
>garage door movement at a preset (limit) position.

The Eaton Electric switch is an overkill, costs a lot too.  Go to any
electronics shop and look for a similar switch to the Cherry switch
with a lever found in
http://www.cherrycorp.com/products/US/switches/saesgp.htm

Choose a suitable sized one.  There are two screw holes on the body
for your to mount the switch inside an box so as to enclose the wiring
connections.
David Efflandt - 29 Feb 2004 07:49 GMT
> I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
> luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> needed and then simply turned off using he wall switch when the house
> has been entered.

What, you never heard of x10.com?  Or Radio Shack has their Plug'n
Power version (not sure if IBM still sells their version).  These are all
compatible remote control modules (including wall switches).  Wireless
remotes are available with either a key fob with 2 switches or larger
remote that can control up to 16 modules.  Not sure what the wireless
range is, but the module with antenna downstairs (which allows control of
other modules) works from remote upstairs.

But check total watts of the lights involved.  10 lamps may be too much
for a wall switch module (even if just 60 or 75 watt bulbs).  Besides an
appliance module, there is a heavy duty appliance module.

Signature

David Efflandt - All spam ignored  http://www.de-srv.com/

Rob Gray - 29 Feb 2004 10:49 GMT
>>I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
>>luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.
[quoted text clipped - 33 lines]
> for a wall switch module (even if just 60 or 75 watt bulbs).  Besides an
> appliance module, there is a heavy duty appliance module.

Thanks for the feedback. Regarding Radio Shack, I have described to
clerks in their stores a few times what I was looking for and was told
that they have no such product. For that reason, I'm not confident that
Radio Shack has such a solution. As to the "X10.com", I've been to their
site and I think I could get the lights to be controlled via a remote
control if I set up an elaborate home wireless setup. I'm just looking
for a simple, remote contol wall switch though, not something very
elaborate.....
HA HA Budys Here - 29 Feb 2004 14:56 GMT
>From: Rob Gray SlateMan@epix.net

>Thanks for the feedback. Regarding Radio Shack, I have described to
>clerks in their stores a few times what I was looking for and was told
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>for a simple, remote contol wall switch though, not something very
>elaborate.....

Apparently you think you need to automate your entire home in order to
accomplish automating 1 single switch and that is not the case.

You need a plug-in receiver, a 2-button keychain remote, and replace the
existing wall switch for the floodlights with an X-10 compatible wall switch
(not dimmer) module.

X-10 and most radio shacks have exactly what you need.
Rob Gray - 29 Feb 2004 17:06 GMT
>>From: Rob Gray SlateMan@epix.net
>
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
>
> X-10 and most radio shacks have exactly what you need.

Cool, thanks for the info.... These lights are not "dimmable" lights
though. I wonder if it will be a problem to put them on an X10 dimmer
switch?
HA HA Budys Here - 29 Feb 2004 18:31 GMT
>From: Rob Gray SlateMan@epix.net

>Cool, thanks for the info.... These lights are not "dimmable" lights
>though. I wonder if it will be a problem to put them on an X10 dimmer
>switch?

I suggested the non-dim variety as it can handle a large load, like 10 possibly
150w floodlights. The dimmer modules tend to have a 500-600 watt rating.
Rob Gray - 29 Feb 2004 11:02 GMT
>>I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
>>luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.
[quoted text clipped - 33 lines]
> for a wall switch module (even if just 60 or 75 watt bulbs).  Besides an
> appliance module, there is a heavy duty appliance module.

Thanks fo the advice. I'm looking for a single remote to control a
single switch, not something to turn on and off things throughout the
house, but I'll check those places again. Maybe they've come up with new
stuff since I last visited....

Rob
Martin - 29 Feb 2004 14:09 GMT
Just checked the X-10 site.  They still have a live chat connection. Why
don't you ask them if it could be set up as you want?   The only problem I
can see is the range of their key chain remote, about 100 ft.   In my Buick
the built-in remote, as someone else described, extends the range to about
200 ft down the driveway.

> >>I have asked this question to a newsgroup or two in the past with no
> >>luck, but I figure with technology changing, maybe I'll get lucky now.
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> >>needed and then simply turned off using he wall switch when the house
> >>has been entered.
xymergy@suds.com - 29 Feb 2004 15:31 GMT
>Thanks fo the advice. I'm looking for a single remote to control a
>single switch, not something to turn on and off things throughout the
>house, but I'll check those places again. Maybe they've come up with new
>stuff since I last visited....

Seriously, look at the X-10 stuff and consider the possibility of
using a handheld remote to activate the light as opposed to the
wall-mounted switch you seem fixated on.  This will require a
transmitter plugged in somewhere nearby for the remote to communicate
with the light.
m Ransley - 29 Feb 2004 16:13 GMT
Program your cars 2 extra buttons using x10 or a radio shack controller-
transmitter.  Set your car to receive code and you can program 2-ONs or
a on-off sequence. Two ONs give you control of 2 separate light circuts,
which you would turn off upon entering your house with your regular x10-
radioshack controler. The third button program in your garage door. Each
of the 3 car buttons are only taking one code. Not an On -Off code, its
either On or Off.
m Ransley - 29 Feb 2004 10:10 GMT
You realy have not done any reasearch......          For 20 yrs X 10
has been the coolest set up.  I have a set up that when i pull in the
garage  the x 10 motion detector turns on the garage lights, that garage
unit  digitaly through  existing wires turns on 4 more sensors  one in
the house to. so you drive in to a LIT  house and yard.  And inside
units can turn them all off.
Every GM  and  probably other makes  that have the built in garage door
openers can also be programed to interface with X 10 .  And maybe even
regular door remotes.  They dont tell you this as they want you to buy
their equipment , What BS ... My Caddy  DHS  I programed  the door
opener [ built in with 3 buttons ]  2 extra buttons to controll X 10
lights so i turn on or off  outside and interior lights.  Even the Caddy
dealer didnt know it could be done.. Yes x 10 is cool and computer
controlable to.   One  outside sensor  can control  8 additional units -
be controled  and has a multitude of settings .
It honestly took me many , many   days to plan and learn the system  as
i needed it but i have  a fully automated system from car - before entry
to indoor dimming and sound warning  of  activation  to motion recorded
time event vcr  +  DVD  event  recording .    There isnt anything you
cant do with  X 10  . Radioshack , Cadilac GM  , and most any  Pulse
Binary  aftermarket system can be adapted,  Alarms- Remote monitoring-
water- heat - motion -  any sensor in any combo could be controled from
your car or bedroom  using wireless  handheld or  AC powered   wireless
.....   X 10  its been around a long time ...
Just seal outside sensors where the wires enter and dont even approach
the rated limit  for watts , their RELAYS are crappy
Rob Gray - 29 Feb 2004 10:51 GMT
Actually, I have...... I looked at the X10 site, but did not find a
single remote that could control a single wall switch from outside as I
described it. Thanks for the insult though... lol....

> You realy have not done any reasearch......          
Curmudgeon - 29 Feb 2004 14:49 GMT
Here is exactly what you need...cost $25.99.
http://www.smarthome.com/4003.html  This includes outlet for plug in lamp or
anything else.

If you must have a wall switch to go with it, add
http://www.smarthome.com/2031.html  for another $12.

Total cost with wall switch under $40.   If that's too high,  then you
really don't want it bad enough.  Nothing cheaper that I know of.  There is
no wall switch with built in RF receiver.

> Actually, I have...... I looked at the X10 site, but did not find a
> single remote that could control a single wall switch from outside as I
> described it. Thanks for the insult though... lol....
>
> > You realy have not done any reasearch......
HA HA Budys Here - 29 Feb 2004 15:00 GMT
>From: Rob Gray SlateMan@epix.net

>Actually, I have...... I looked at the X10 site, but did not find a
>single remote that could control a single wall switch from outside as I
>described it. Thanks for the insult though... lol....

No, you'll just have to settle for the 2-address key fob and the plug-in
receiver along with 1 wall switch module.

The only thing this would have that you don't want is an extra on/off rocker
switch on the key fob. They don't make a single-address remote control key fob.


HA HA Budys Here - 29 Feb 2004 14:52 GMT
>From: ransley@webtv.net

>You realy have not done any reasearch......          For 20 yrs X 10
>has been the coolest set up.  I have a set up that when i pull in the
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
> Just seal outside sensors where the wires enter and dont even approach
>the rated limit  for watts , their RELAYS are crappy

Ransley, how did you program your GM buttons?
Edwin Pawlowski - 29 Feb 2004 14:56 GMT
"HA HA Budys Here" <hahabudyshere@aol.com> wrote in message

> Ransley, how did you program your GM buttons?

I have the three button setup on a Buick. I used the remote for the grage
door to programthat one, then the wirelyess remove for the X-10 to program
the other buttons.  It reads the signal and duplicates it.  There is a Home
Link web page that should describe it better. Or your owners manual

Nice to be able to turn lights on from the car if you come home late.
I-zheet M'drurz - 29 Feb 2004 15:10 GMT
> You realy have not done any reasearch......          For 20 yrs
> X 10 has been the coolest set up.

  (endless X-10 raving snipped)

  Why do you insist on drawing him blueprints for an armored tank
  when all he needs is a pea shooter?

Signature

  No more big'uns for me, now I'm a 'Venture Capitalist'.
  I've learned to totally appreciate 'Small Firms'.

I-zheet M'drurz - 29 Feb 2004 13:29 GMT
> Does anyone know of a company that sells a wireless remote
> control wall light switch? Such a solution would work great
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
> Thank in advance for any advice.

  Try the "ceiling fans" area of THD or Lowe's.  I bought one of
  these 10 years ago, I would think they still make them.  

  It's a "fake" wall switch that's actually a transmitter, battery
  holder, and what looks like a common ivory wall switch.  It's
  made for relocating a light switch in a room where you don't
  want to start rewiring through walls, this entire box surface
  mounts, it looks like a shallow Wiremold box.

  Anyway, the -receiver- end of this thing gets wired into a
  junction box in the circuit where you can access the wires going
  to the light fixture(s) typically in the basement or attic.  
  you flip the "dummy" switch on the wall and it xmits to the
  receive unit and makes the actual connection there, and the
  fixture is enegrized.

  Only thing you might do diifferent is invest a buck in a metal
  "utility" box and cover plate with rounded corners, so the
  original mounting box doesn't damage your car interior if it
  gets tossed around.

  You would need to isolate the intented light fixtures and feed
  them from the indoor receiver, but that sounds like it would be
  the easy part.

Signature

  No more big'uns for me, now I'm a 'Venture Capitalist'.
  I've learned to totally appreciate 'Small Firms'.

I-zheet M'drurz - 29 Feb 2004 14:21 GMT
  Only thing is that this is rated for 350 watts of lighting only,
  which means that whole string of flood lights on one circuit
  would likely be overloading it.  There are ways to get around
  that (either isolate and control 2 or 3 key fixtures or rig up
  some sort of relay situation to control the whole circuit, but
  I have no idea of your preferences)

  http://www.smarthome.com/2533T.HTML

  This allows you to still use your indoor switch to turn them off,
  something I overlooked in my previous reply.  Same deal with the
  "remote": throw away the "supplied drywall screws" and buy a nice
  rounded corners electrical box for it.

Signature

  No more big'uns for me, now I'm a 'Venture Capitalist'.
  I've learned to totally appreciate 'Small Firms'.

Edwin Pawlowski - 29 Feb 2004 14:10 GMT
>    Only thing is that this is rated for 350 watts of lighting only,
>    which means that whole string of flood lights on one circuit
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
>    http://www.smarthome.com/2533T.HTML

There are remote appliance modules that can handle 20 amps. Same as the X-10
modules.
Signature

Ed
esp@snet.net
http://pages.cthome.net/edhome

SQLit - 29 Feb 2004 14:37 GMT
snipped

> Does anyone know of a company that sells a wireless remote control wall
> light switch? Such a solution would work great since the remote control
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
> Rob

I just bought a new home and the craftsman garage door opener was lost in
translation.
So I went to sears and bought a new opener for my truck. This remote has 3
buttons. Big one is programmed for the door and button #3 is programmed into
a plug in device that will handle 600 watts. Really designed for a lamp but
I am sure you can figure it out.

Sears also had the coolest wall switch. It has a motion sensor on it. I open
the garage door and the lights automatically turn on. Leave and they turn
off.

Spent right about  $100.00 for all three devices.  Now I know your saying
that you do not have a Craftsman door opener, which is built by Chamberlain.
There is a "Clicker" remote that does the same thing, just get the one for
your garage door. I am sure they are using the X-10 or similar technology.

I can drive up in the day time open the garage door. At night I pull into
the drive way and push two buttons. Lights on inside and out.
This should be your solution...
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2010 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.