On 3/20/06 7:18 AM, in article fj6t129uq73ohhr9mqbknitgg6frcfptpo@4ax.com,
>> Has anyone here tried this with either the Topsy-Turvy I or II tomato
>> planter systems?
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
>
> Jim
Could it be sheer novelty? I've seen the Topsy-Turvey tomatoes well grown,
dripping with red and green fruits and it is "fun". It makes me smile.
I've never tasted the tomatoes, so I can't address that.
Cheryl
Rick - 20 Mar 2006 16:52 GMT
>On 3/20/06 7:18 AM, in article fj6t129uq73ohhr9mqbknitgg6frcfptpo@4ax.com,
>
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
>
>Cheryl
I've grown tomatoes three ways (upside down, in the ground and in containers)
for the past three years. I use 5 gallon buckets (like paint buckets) for
upside down growth, not the store bought devices. I modified them by placing a
hole in the bottom for the plants, and then inserted a papercup to act as a
mols which I surrounded with spray insulation foam (Great Stuff). That made a
several inch reservoir for water in the bottom of the bucket. Last year the
upside down plants did the best. Those in containers or the ground got hit hard
with a powdery mildew like fungus because it was so dry (I know,
counterintuitive but that's what the experts said). The most amasing yields
were the small types of tomatoes. I tried some big heirlooms and they split
pretty bad (also split in the other methods).
Advantages of upside down- no staking or cages, easy to pick, less disease as
plants are up in a breeze that keeps foliage dry, easy to water from the deck
(they hang of my deck railing), high yields. Plants are planted deep (full
depth of 5 gallon bucket)so they get off to a fast start. Kind of fun, and
people get a kick out of it.
Disadvantages: I have to water frequently, and I've had trouble with splitting
and blossom end rot due to erratic watering. I noticed the commercial grow
bags have a couple of layers of foam rubber to hold water, and I am going to
try that this year.
As to taste- I did not find any dfference.
On the day of Mon, 20 Mar 2006 07:18:28 -0500...
Jim Elbrecht <elbrecht@email.com>
typed these letters:
>>Has anyone here tried this with either the Topsy-Turvy I or II tomato
>>planter systems?
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
>
>Jim
The answer has to be novelty. Otherwise it's just unnatural. If one
has enough space to grow tomatoes in a container upside down. One
has enough space to grow them right side up in a container. The
upside down tomato concept makes no sense to me... Then again
a lot of things in the world make no sense to me.
Devonshire